My biggest cruise trend gripe is the end of "All Inclusive" sailing. How many cruise lines now charge for room service, lobster tails at dinner, specialty dining, cappuccinos, etc.. These things used to be free!
I have had largely positive experiences on my 9 HAL cruises. Everything from Inside Cabins to Suites!
I find the food better on HAL than on other mainstream cruise lines! And it is a more sophisticated crowd (some people call that an old crowd).